I wrote an article on the "We are Jane Doe" and "I am Jane Doe".
As a man, I stand firm that women do not want men to "protect" them. They want men to stand beside them. They want men to stop being assholes and abusing them.
Honestly, I think the assumptive premise is wrong. It never once occurred to me to believe that men truly think women want this. They know we DON'T want it. That's 100% the appeal. They are taking something that would be denied them if consent was involved. Increasingly, I think the subset of men that needs to be interrogated isn't the one "confused" by what women want, but the increasingly large subset that hates women and derives their entertainment from torturing and degrading them, particularly when it comes to sex, which they view as being "unfairly" withheld from them by women who shouldn't get to have any opinion whatsoever about what is done to their bodies.
It's become obvious that the solution cannot be found in reforming men: we must harden women. Pubescent girls should take instruction not only about their biology but also assertiveness training and self-defense techniques. Adult women should marshal themselves to watch over each other in all social situations, whether it's running in a park or attending a party. Check-in's on the phone, having a wing-woman, and going out in small groups need to become the norm, as should pursuing active physical defense techniques and even weapons training for concealed carry. We should stop giving males deference for the illusion that they are "protectors" when the few who are predators can do so much damage.
The science of semiotics (non-verbal communication) in fashion teaches that high heels symbolize sexual submission in females by visually marking her sex. In 20thC Western culture, high heels accentuated fashion’s newly-revealed legs under shorter skirts. High heels changed from representing high status (think Louis XIV and his red ones) and practicality (the pattens to navigate filthy medieval streets) into the fetish they became (looking at you David Byrne). Other cultures adopted different semiotics to express female subjugation, for example, foot-binding in China and hijab in the Mideast. Consider that working women—nurses, teachers, stock clerks, moms—do not wear heels; heels are reserved for runways, red carpets, pole dancers, drag queens, and trophy wives. We wear them on special occasions with our best outfits when we want to show we are females who epitomize glamour, because as Gina Lollabrigida opined in an earlier era, “Glamour is when a man knows a woman is a woman.” It’s all costuming over time, and it’s always in transition.
My first reaction to your proposal was negative @Lorraine but now I’m thinking “if that’s what it takes, let’s do it”. Even though these measures might keep young women safer in the outside world, we all know that abusers are most often found in the family, neighbourhood or community, where the abuse begins earlier than in puberty.
Two years ago, I was interested to read that Project 2025 included the goal of eliminating online porn and a ban on such websites. Have not seen a damn thing about that, you pinch-nosed, picayune, bloodless Heritage Foundation types.
It is a mistake to call these weirdos "men". They are not. They are males, yes, but they never matured, grew up and graduated to manhood. No man would be even slightly interested in raping a woman. The problem for women is that the man graduation rate is really low. The percent that make it, if I had to guess, might be 20%.
The problem is, they 100% ARE men. They are a large percentage of men and pretending they are outliers not fit to be defined as men is absolutely reinforcing the idea that there's nothing wrong with our current conception of maleness or what is acceptable / expected in men. Your comment is basically saying that no one qualifies as a "man" unless they don't act or think the way a large percentage of men act and think. I know you're trying to distinguish "good" men from "bad" men, but this type of framing absolutely minimizes the problem. This IS men. This is how many many men behave and think. Thus the problem in our culture. We need to face that head on.
We men know that the Trumps, Hegseth's and Tate brothers of this world are not remotely manly. They fake it every step of the way. They have to. They don't know any better and are not capable of learning. Also, they are impossible to communicate with. They understand nothing. And they are violently protective of their failed status. Ask any woman if she saw any men on January 6th. The answer is no, none. But a lot of males all gussied up to look like what they think men look like. This is a global crisis.
I think it's delusional to think this is some minority of men when all of us women see the opposite in every new example on the news and in our everyday lives. I get why it's comforting to think this somehow doesn't represent men, but that's not my (or most women's) experience, unfortunately. Putting "real men" on a pedestal is part of the problem, frankly - every one of these manosphere types thinks they are absolute pinnacle of manhood. But I guess we'll just get more think pieces in the news as to why women don't want to get married and have children and wait on these guys, and how horrible and selfish women are for this and how we should lower our standards or have our rights increasingly stripped from us to force us into sleeping with / marrying these guys. I think until we face the fact this IS men in many women's lived experience, the problem will never be solved.
My point exactly. 100% of women are seeing something like 80% Arrested Development Males (ADMs) who simply cannot cut it in any kind of normal relationship. Since we evolved from our first hominid ancestors until maybe half a century ago, being an ADM was all a male needed to survive, prosper and support a family, No more. Look at how in the information world the power of the female intellect has roared forward. ADM manosphere pinnacle of manhood behavior is simply irrelevant in our world. As the Tate brothers show, their irrelevance is driving the ADMs absolutely crazy. Worse, this leaves only a small percent of women able to create a relationship with a man. In China this has become a major policy problem for The Party: how to keep ADMs on top and still gain and keep global market share. Won't work.
I don't think they care what women want - they only care what pleases themselves, never thinking beyond the moment. This is infantilism writ large in the manosphere.
Being in a relationship with my beloved partner for nearly 10 years, I can’t begin to tell you how many transformation of love I went through. I am a completely different man now than I was before, and this is a natural process that occur when a man actually love a women and decide to try to meet her, day after day, after month, after year. The relationship gets deeper, and the deeper it gets, the more intimacy there is.
Today I am on my knee, humble by life itself for giving me the chance to be able to share complete vulnerability, openness and intimacy with another human being, and for having the chance to meet with love and the unbelievable pain and joy that comes with it.
She’s everything to me.
How endlessly pitiful and ignorant are the degraded males of this sad movement of Power through Penis, or whatever else they come up with. They can’t tell me they ever met love.
They can’t tell me they are men either.
What they are is the result of denial of their true nature, and the manufacturing of an image of power to try to hold on. So wasteful.
We need to bring back castration...on another note, what they hell are they teaching at Cornell? I know it's the preeminent veterinarian school, but how is Ketamine so prevalent there? Why do they have such easy access to it? Mama's teach your boys to respect and revere women...
Women are learning to want nothing that involves subservience. They are learning they can use any variety of anon sperm to have a child. How many men are thanked by children saying, “He stuck by us and worked four jobs.” Payback time you mother fuckers. There’s your root of linguistic changes in culture.
What do men think women want? That's an easy one: money. Ironically, I know this from having married two men who married me because they wanted me to support them while #1 sat around waiting for people to die and #2 sat around drinking himself to death.
What Freud said about women having penis envy, I’ve always thought that it’s the exact opposite — that men have always been so curious (and jealous) about women’s nature and ability to create new life inside her body and then her body’s extraordinary ability to birth and nourish life.
Unfortunately, these days, per pastor Doug Wilson, “women are just people other people come out of”….. yet another form of dehumanization.
Women don’t have penis envy, men have “birth envy”, because they have been conditioned to be in a place of authority and do not like being out of control when it comes to women. 🤷🏼♀️
Regarding men "protecting" women, there is a thing where a man sees a woman being approached unwelcomed by a man. The man can wait and watch to make sure that she is not being harassed or violated. Watched to see if she is handling it on her own.
In the first inkling that the woman is being harassed or worse, violated and appears unable to control the situation, then sure, a man can make the decision to step in. The man can opt approach the bartender and/or a bouncer (door guard) and explain the situation and have them be watchful.
One approach that I have taken in the past—but one be very cautious of this approach as it can backfire—I walked up to the woman and acted as a friend or even boyfriend.
BUT! The first step is to cause men (and frat boys) to simply stop violating women!
@ymb I’ve never read it, but I well remember Andrea Dworkin, Germaine Greer and many other writers of the period. They changed me for good and forever.
She also studied and analysed the whole industry of pornography, including the images themselves; she helped us gain insight and understanding of the hidden and symbolic meanings in pornography, the narrow range of recurring themes, the masochistic and misogynistic ways in which women were portrayed. There is nothing healthy or positive in pornography; it’s ugly, exploitative and inhumane.
You mean Andrea Dworkin? A bestselling author, unlike you. She had stats to back up how many female porn participants were child abuse victims. Yeah. They liked it. It was what they knew. How they got housed clothed and fed . I don't doubt women who choose sex work. Children don't.
"Of course, the presumption is that those 1,200 women are lying". Statistically, yes, some will be lying. There have been other college-related cases where it was found the woman lied. One in New Jersey (I forgot the names), the college woman who took it up to drag across a mattress across her campus, and the infamous Duke University case, which I KNEW from the beginning. Why? The chances of a White guy raping a black woman is Zero (according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice for the last 10 years or so). It's best to wait for the process to take its course.
I wrote an article on the "We are Jane Doe" and "I am Jane Doe".
As a man, I stand firm that women do not want men to "protect" them. They want men to stand beside them. They want men to stop being assholes and abusing them.
Honestly, I think the assumptive premise is wrong. It never once occurred to me to believe that men truly think women want this. They know we DON'T want it. That's 100% the appeal. They are taking something that would be denied them if consent was involved. Increasingly, I think the subset of men that needs to be interrogated isn't the one "confused" by what women want, but the increasingly large subset that hates women and derives their entertainment from torturing and degrading them, particularly when it comes to sex, which they view as being "unfairly" withheld from them by women who shouldn't get to have any opinion whatsoever about what is done to their bodies.
It's become obvious that the solution cannot be found in reforming men: we must harden women. Pubescent girls should take instruction not only about their biology but also assertiveness training and self-defense techniques. Adult women should marshal themselves to watch over each other in all social situations, whether it's running in a park or attending a party. Check-in's on the phone, having a wing-woman, and going out in small groups need to become the norm, as should pursuing active physical defense techniques and even weapons training for concealed carry. We should stop giving males deference for the illusion that they are "protectors" when the few who are predators can do so much damage.
And stop hobbling around on high heels. Just sayin’.
Hobbled is the correct word; men love to see us hobbling - I wonder why?
The science of semiotics (non-verbal communication) in fashion teaches that high heels symbolize sexual submission in females by visually marking her sex. In 20thC Western culture, high heels accentuated fashion’s newly-revealed legs under shorter skirts. High heels changed from representing high status (think Louis XIV and his red ones) and practicality (the pattens to navigate filthy medieval streets) into the fetish they became (looking at you David Byrne). Other cultures adopted different semiotics to express female subjugation, for example, foot-binding in China and hijab in the Mideast. Consider that working women—nurses, teachers, stock clerks, moms—do not wear heels; heels are reserved for runways, red carpets, pole dancers, drag queens, and trophy wives. We wear them on special occasions with our best outfits when we want to show we are females who epitomize glamour, because as Gina Lollabrigida opined in an earlier era, “Glamour is when a man knows a woman is a woman.” It’s all costuming over time, and it’s always in transition.
Absolutely this.
My first reaction to your proposal was negative @Lorraine but now I’m thinking “if that’s what it takes, let’s do it”. Even though these measures might keep young women safer in the outside world, we all know that abusers are most often found in the family, neighbourhood or community, where the abuse begins earlier than in puberty.
Two years ago, I was interested to read that Project 2025 included the goal of eliminating online porn and a ban on such websites. Have not seen a damn thing about that, you pinch-nosed, picayune, bloodless Heritage Foundation types.
so you want that eliminated?
MY POINT was that the Project 2025 drones threatened to do it but never followed through: Pornographia interrupta.
It is a mistake to call these weirdos "men". They are not. They are males, yes, but they never matured, grew up and graduated to manhood. No man would be even slightly interested in raping a woman. The problem for women is that the man graduation rate is really low. The percent that make it, if I had to guess, might be 20%.
The problem is, they 100% ARE men. They are a large percentage of men and pretending they are outliers not fit to be defined as men is absolutely reinforcing the idea that there's nothing wrong with our current conception of maleness or what is acceptable / expected in men. Your comment is basically saying that no one qualifies as a "man" unless they don't act or think the way a large percentage of men act and think. I know you're trying to distinguish "good" men from "bad" men, but this type of framing absolutely minimizes the problem. This IS men. This is how many many men behave and think. Thus the problem in our culture. We need to face that head on.
We men know that the Trumps, Hegseth's and Tate brothers of this world are not remotely manly. They fake it every step of the way. They have to. They don't know any better and are not capable of learning. Also, they are impossible to communicate with. They understand nothing. And they are violently protective of their failed status. Ask any woman if she saw any men on January 6th. The answer is no, none. But a lot of males all gussied up to look like what they think men look like. This is a global crisis.
I think it's delusional to think this is some minority of men when all of us women see the opposite in every new example on the news and in our everyday lives. I get why it's comforting to think this somehow doesn't represent men, but that's not my (or most women's) experience, unfortunately. Putting "real men" on a pedestal is part of the problem, frankly - every one of these manosphere types thinks they are absolute pinnacle of manhood. But I guess we'll just get more think pieces in the news as to why women don't want to get married and have children and wait on these guys, and how horrible and selfish women are for this and how we should lower our standards or have our rights increasingly stripped from us to force us into sleeping with / marrying these guys. I think until we face the fact this IS men in many women's lived experience, the problem will never be solved.
My point exactly. 100% of women are seeing something like 80% Arrested Development Males (ADMs) who simply cannot cut it in any kind of normal relationship. Since we evolved from our first hominid ancestors until maybe half a century ago, being an ADM was all a male needed to survive, prosper and support a family, No more. Look at how in the information world the power of the female intellect has roared forward. ADM manosphere pinnacle of manhood behavior is simply irrelevant in our world. As the Tate brothers show, their irrelevance is driving the ADMs absolutely crazy. Worse, this leaves only a small percent of women able to create a relationship with a man. In China this has become a major policy problem for The Party: how to keep ADMs on top and still gain and keep global market share. Won't work.
I don't think they care what women want - they only care what pleases themselves, never thinking beyond the moment. This is infantilism writ large in the manosphere.
Let's not forget: this is a frat hazing activity meant to create a shame bond between the participants.
That's horrifying. I haven't seen that written about.
It’s so difficult to read because it’s so brutally honest. We must face these issues.
Great article, sad in content but so important.
Being in a relationship with my beloved partner for nearly 10 years, I can’t begin to tell you how many transformation of love I went through. I am a completely different man now than I was before, and this is a natural process that occur when a man actually love a women and decide to try to meet her, day after day, after month, after year. The relationship gets deeper, and the deeper it gets, the more intimacy there is.
Today I am on my knee, humble by life itself for giving me the chance to be able to share complete vulnerability, openness and intimacy with another human being, and for having the chance to meet with love and the unbelievable pain and joy that comes with it.
She’s everything to me.
How endlessly pitiful and ignorant are the degraded males of this sad movement of Power through Penis, or whatever else they come up with. They can’t tell me they ever met love.
They can’t tell me they are men either.
What they are is the result of denial of their true nature, and the manufacturing of an image of power to try to hold on. So wasteful.
@Laurent a relationship of the depth you describe is a rare occurrence, denied to most of us by the misogyny we feel around us.
We need to bring back castration...on another note, what they hell are they teaching at Cornell? I know it's the preeminent veterinarian school, but how is Ketamine so prevalent there? Why do they have such easy access to it? Mama's teach your boys to respect and revere women...
they are teaching wokeness, like in all of academia.
I think ketamine is used a lot in veterinarian medicine. Hmmm…
Women are learning to want nothing that involves subservience. They are learning they can use any variety of anon sperm to have a child. How many men are thanked by children saying, “He stuck by us and worked four jobs.” Payback time you mother fuckers. There’s your root of linguistic changes in culture.
What do men think women want? That's an easy one: money. Ironically, I know this from having married two men who married me because they wanted me to support them while #1 sat around waiting for people to die and #2 sat around drinking himself to death.
Shouldn’t your question therefore be “What do women think men want?”.
What do women think men want? That's also and easy one: sex.
🤣 that’s the answer to “what do we all know men want?”
And it doesn't matter much with whom or with what. 🤣
those are outliers.
What Freud said about women having penis envy, I’ve always thought that it’s the exact opposite — that men have always been so curious (and jealous) about women’s nature and ability to create new life inside her body and then her body’s extraordinary ability to birth and nourish life.
Unfortunately, these days, per pastor Doug Wilson, “women are just people other people come out of”….. yet another form of dehumanization.
Women don’t have penis envy, men have “birth envy”, because they have been conditioned to be in a place of authority and do not like being out of control when it comes to women. 🤷🏼♀️
pure nonsense.
Regarding men "protecting" women, there is a thing where a man sees a woman being approached unwelcomed by a man. The man can wait and watch to make sure that she is not being harassed or violated. Watched to see if she is handling it on her own.
In the first inkling that the woman is being harassed or worse, violated and appears unable to control the situation, then sure, a man can make the decision to step in. The man can opt approach the bartender and/or a bouncer (door guard) and explain the situation and have them be watchful.
One approach that I have taken in the past—but one be very cautious of this approach as it can backfire—I walked up to the woman and acted as a friend or even boyfriend.
BUT! The first step is to cause men (and frat boys) to simply stop violating women!
MEN, STOP BEING ASSHOLES!
Thanks for this! And thanks for putting me on to Jackson Katz. I hope to catch your interview.
Looking at my copy of Valerie Solanas' SCUM Manifesto.🥰
@ymb I’ve never read it, but I well remember Andrea Dworkin, Germaine Greer and many other writers of the period. They changed me for good and forever.
the same Dworking who was against womein doing pornography even if they liked it?
She also studied and analysed the whole industry of pornography, including the images themselves; she helped us gain insight and understanding of the hidden and symbolic meanings in pornography, the narrow range of recurring themes, the masochistic and misogynistic ways in which women were portrayed. There is nothing healthy or positive in pornography; it’s ugly, exploitative and inhumane.
You mean Andrea Dworkin? A bestselling author, unlike you. She had stats to back up how many female porn participants were child abuse victims. Yeah. They liked it. It was what they knew. How they got housed clothed and fed . I don't doubt women who choose sex work. Children don't.
"Of course, the presumption is that those 1,200 women are lying". Statistically, yes, some will be lying. There have been other college-related cases where it was found the woman lied. One in New Jersey (I forgot the names), the college woman who took it up to drag across a mattress across her campus, and the infamous Duke University case, which I KNEW from the beginning. Why? The chances of a White guy raping a black woman is Zero (according to the U.S. Bureau of Justice for the last 10 years or so). It's best to wait for the process to take its course.
Do you think all the Epstein victims are lying?